Building Blocks for Youth
Juvenile Justice Issues
State by State Information
Research
Newsroom
About Us
About Us
Contact Us
  FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 2, 2000

Contact: Tommy McDonald, Liz Heller, Michael Shellenberger, 415-255-1946

California: Youth of Color 2.5 Times More Likely than White Kids to be Tried as Adults; 8.3 Times More Likely to be Incarcerated by Adult Court, New Study Finds

NAACP, MALDEF, Other Civil Rights Groups Demand State Investigation into Racial Bias

Color of Justice Study First in a Series by New Building Blocks for Youth Initiative


WHAT: News Conferences in Sacramento, Los Angeles
WHEN: 10:00A.M. (LA); 11:00A.M. (Sacramento) Wednesday, February 2, 2000
WHO: Civil rights groups, children's advocates, former youth offenders, criminal justice experts
WHERE: Governor's Press Room, The Capitol, Sacramento, MALDEF offices, 634 S. Spring Street at 6th and 7th Streets, Los Angeles

SACRAMENTO/LOS ANGELES, CA - California civil rights leaders and children's advocates will release a new study February 2 that shows that African American, Latino and Asian American youth are significantly more likely to be transferred to adult court and sentenced to incarceration than white youths who commit comparable crimes.

At Sacramento and Los Angeles news conferences Wednesday, civil rights groups will demand that Governor Gray Davis investigate the report's findings and take measures to address racial disparities in juvenile transfers.

"Even at a time of heightened public awareness of racism in the criminal justice system, it's shocking to find such huge discrepancies in the way Latino and African American kids are treated," said Beatriz Lopez-Flores, Vice President of Community Education and Public Policy for MALDEF."A justice system that displays such blatant bias is a system in dire need of reform. We're calling on Governor Davis to send a clear message that discrimination is unacceptable in California's justice system and we hope the Governor will do whatever it takes to ensure that youth of color receive fair treatment, whether they are tried as juveniles or adults."

Though past studies have documented that minorities are overrepresented in the juvenile justice system, this study by the Justice Policy Institute (JPI), a San Francisco, CA- and Washington, DC- based think-tank on criminal justice, is the first to document the cumulative effect of racial bias when youths are transferred to the adult system.

"The imbalances this study reveals are stark, vast and deeply disturbing," said Dan Macallair, associate director of JPI and co-author of The Color of Justice. "Discrimination against kids of color accumulates at every stage of the justice system and skyrockets when juveniles are tried as adults. California has a double standard: throw kids of color behind bars, but rehabilitate white kids who commit comparable crimes. The report focuses primarily on data from Los Angeles County, which accounts for 40 percent of cases transferred to adult court in the state. L.A. is also the only county that keeps a detailed record regarding its transfers.

The study found that:

  • After transfer to the adult system, African American youth offenders are 18.4 times more likely, Asian youth offenders are 4.5 times more likely, and Latino youth offenders are 7.3 times more likely than white youth offenders to be sentenced by an adult court to CYA confinement.
  • Compared to white youths, minority youths are 2.8 times more likely to be arrested for a violent crime, 6.2 times more likely to wind up in adult court, and 7 times more likely to be sent to prison by adult court.
  • Compared to white youths accused of similar crimes, minority youth offenders are somewhat more likely to be sentenced to CYA facilities by juvenile courts (minorities constitute 77.0 percent of violent crime arrestees and 84.5 percent of CYA sentencings). But minority youth are much more likely to be sentenced to CYA facilities after transfer to adult courts (77.0 percent of arrests, but 91.1 percent of CYA sentencings).

JPI researchers conducted the study using data from 1993 to 1999 collected from the Los Angeles County Probation Department Research Division, Los Angeles County District Attorney's Office, California Youth Authority Research Division, California Department of Justice Criminal Justice Statistics Center, Department of Finance Demographic Research Division and the U.S. Census Bureau.

"The juvenile justice system was founded 100 years ago with the idea that youth offenders can be rehabilitated," said Mark Soler, President of the Youth Law Center, a San Francisco, CA and Washington, DC- based child advocacy group. "Yet today, even though youth crime is dropping steadily, record numbers of juveniles are being transferred to the adult court and thrown behind bars. As this study shows, these policies are hitting minority kids the hardest."


The Color of Justice, co-authored by Macallair and Mike Males, PhD, a renowned author and researcher on juvenile justice issues at UC Santa Cruz, is the first of five reports to be released this year by the national Building Blocks for Youth initiative. The multi-year initiative works to protect youth of color in the justice system and to promote rational and effective juvenile justice policies through a combination of research, analysis of decision making, direct advocacy, constituency building, and public education.

READ THE STUDY


Building Blocks partners include the the Youth Law Center, American Bar Association Juvenile Justice Center, Communication Works, Communications Consortium Media Center, Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice, Juvenile Law Center, Minorities in Law Enforcement, National Council on Crime and Delinquency, and Pretrial Services Resource Center. The initiative is supported by the federal Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention and the Bureau of Justice Assistance, and the Annie E. Casey, Ford, Walter Johnson, The John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur, and Rockefeller Foundations, and the Center on Crime, Communities & Culture of the Open Society Institute




Home / Juvenile Justice Issues / State-by-State Info / Research
Newsroom / About Us / BBY Partners / Contact us

Building Blocks for Youth
For a fair and effective youth justice system

...a comprehensive effort to protect minority youth in the justice system
and to promote rational and effective juvenile justice policies...